Showing posts with label answers. Show all posts
Showing posts with label answers. Show all posts

Friday, May 1, 2020

An Athiest's Guide to the Bible: The Garden of Eden


We’ve covered off the first several billion years (or 6000 years, depending on which camp you’re in) of Earth’s history in the previous Guide. Now we’re going into a bit more detail with the Garden of Eden. We’re looking at the mechanics of the Garden of Eden, not the events: that comes next in the next Guide.
When the Lord God made the universe, there were no plants of the earth and no seeds had sprouted, because he had not sent any rain, and there was no-one to cultivate the land; but water would come up from beneath the surface and water the ground.
Again, we have this conjoining of the universe and planet Earth. In the bible, the Earth is the entire universe. We could be even more narrow in our interpretation, and state that the Middle East in the entire universe because, for all intents and purposes, the writers of the bible didn’t travel much so had no idea of what was outside of their sphere of influence.

Also, the idea that rain is the only source of water above ground is nonsense as we know of many plants which collect water from the atmosphere in the form of condensation.

Lastly, plants don’t necessarily need cultivating to survive. Many areas of the world are not cultivated by humans, some not even inhabited by humans. We know, scientifically, that plants existed long before even simple animal forms, therefor cultivation is a redundant idea when talking generally about plants. Cultivation, in fact, is only needed when plants are grown as crops for consumption.
Then the Lord God took some soil from the ground and formed a man out of it; he breathed life-giving breath into his nostrils and the man began to live. Then the Lord God planted a garden in Eden, in the East, and there he put the man he had formed.
Laying aside the physical impossibility of soil turning into flesh, if we agree that the God of the Bible is all powerful (read: magic) then it is within the realms of possibility that this God could fashion a human out of soil. It’s not an uncommon device for gods from various cultures to fashion humans out of soil, clay or rock of some sort.

It’s also entirely possible for that god to create a garden in which the human they’ve just created can live. The God of the Bible is not only all powerful but all knowing, so they knew that man would need somewhere to live and something to eat.
He made all kinds of beautiful trees grow there and produce good fruit. In the middle of the garden stood the tree that gives life and the tree that gives knowledge of what is good and what is bad.
In the midst of this garden are these two trees. Of course, no evidence has been found for the existence of either of these trees but the concept of them is fascinating. If I were creating paradise for the creature I had just created I’d want there to be a tree which gives life to those who eat its fruits. Seems pretty reasonable. Then there’s this other tree: the tree that gives knowledge of what is good and what is bad (hereafter known as the tree of knowledge). You’d think knowledge would be a wonderful thing for this creature, this human, to have, especially as you’ve given them the task of naming everything. But it’s not just any knowledge, which might be useful. It’s knowledge of good and bad. But we’ll come back to this in a moment.
A stream flowed in Eden and watered the garden; beyond Eden it divided into four rivers. The first river is the Pishon; it flows around the country of Havilah (pure gold is found there and also rare perfume and precious stones.) The second river is the Gihon; it flows around the country of Cush. The third river is the Tigris, which flows east of Assyria, and the fourth river is the Euphrates.
There is some debate about the exact location of the Garden of Eden, given than only two of the rivers listed are still called what they are in the Bible: the Tigris and the Euphrates. What became of the Pishon and the Gihon rivers is a mystery, as they are no marked on any modern maps. The Tigris and Euphrates rivers join in modern day Iraq, near Basra.

Flowing south is the Shatt al-Arab River, also known as Arvand Rud, which runs into the Persian Gulf. This could be the original stream that flowed through the Garden of Eden. A possibility of some note for the Pishon Rover is the Karun River which joins the Shatt al-Arab River at Khorramshahr in Iran. The Gihon River is somewhat harder to nail down. There are several canals which could follow the paths of ancient rivers. It is entirely possible that the river simply no longer exists.

Some biblical scholars get around this ambiguity by arguing that the flood of Noah’s time (which we will come to in subsequent Guides) has altered the landscape so much that the terrain of the present bears little resemblance to that of the time of the Garden of Eden. I would argue that, given the Bible was written after Noah’s time, the writers might have been able to at least given a more accurate description, with the modern equivalents named in conjunction, especially as it is supposed to be the unerring word of God.

Still others conjecture that it is impossible to tell where the Garden of Eden really was because, when Noah and his descendants named all the places post flood, they could have simply done as early British colonialists did and named things after what they were familiar with, and so the rivers known as the Tigris and the Euphrates might not be in the same location as they were pre-flood, just like there is Wales in the United Kingdom and New South Wales in Australia. This means that the original rivers could have been anywhere in the world. It’s a convenient loophole, if you ask me.

So, where was Eden? Nobody really knows but, if you take the position of the Tigris and Euphrates rivers as they are now, and take the Karun river to be the modern name of the Pishon River, the Garden of Eden was probably located somewhere in the region of the Khuzestan Province of Iran, possibly stretching as far as the Persian Sea.
Then the Lord God placed the man in the Garden of Eden to cultivate it and guard it. He told him, "You may eat the fruit of any tree in the garden, except the tree that gives knowledge of what is good and what is bad. You must not eat the fruit of that tree; if you do, you will die the same day."
This passage raises two questions. The first being, why didn’t God want the human he has created and placed into the Garden to eat the fruit of the Tree of Knowledge? Surely, with God being all knowing, he could see what was going to happen and wouldn’t put temptation in the way. That’s what I’d do, anyway. As a mother, I wouldn’t put a whole plate of cakes in front of my child and tell them they could eat any of the cakes except the one with blue icing, and then be surprised when they ate the one with the blue icing. The caveat, of having said that they’ll die if they do means very little, because the first human would have no concept of death any more than a very young child does.

The second question I have is with exactly the caveat I just mentioned simply because it’s not true. We’ll come to the whole eating of the apple in the next Guide but I will touch on it now. Adam, being that first human that God created and told not to eat from the Tree of Knowledge, didn’t die the same day as eating the apple. We know this because the bible mentions his expulsion from the garden and his children, etc. We could take dying in a more metaphorical sense. This could lend some plausibility to the die-the-same-day concept. It could be taken in a “you’re dead to me” way, in that God rejected them, much as those loving Christians reject their atheist offspring. It could also mean that on that day, Adam brought the concept of death to himself and that previously he was immortal. Either way, it’s a pretty harsh punishment for eating an apple. But we’ll discuss that more in the next Guide.
Then the Lord God said, "It is not good for the man to live alone. I will make a suitable companion to help him." So, he took some soil from the ground and formed all the animals and all the birds. Then he brought them to the man to see what he would name them; and that is how they all got their names.
Now, I don’t know about you but, if I were God, I wouldn’t leave it to a human to name all of my creations. Humans are notoriously bad at naming things. This is why we have scientific names for things, because people are really, really bad at naming things properly. Take the mantis shrimp, for example. It is neither a mantis, nor a shrimp. It falls directly into the say-what-you-see category of naming things. If I were God, I’d get so cranky at Adam for getting all the names so badly wrong, I’d kick him out of the garden for that.

So, the man named all the birds and all the animals; but not one of them was a suitable companion to help him. Then the Lord God made the man fall into a deep sleep, and while he was sleeping, he took out one of the man's ribs and closed up the flesh. He formed a woman out of the rib and brought her to him. Then the man said, "At last, here is one of my own kind - Bone taken from my bone, and flesh from my flesh. "Woman' is her name because she was taken out of man." That is why a man leaves his father and mother and is united with his wife, and they become one. The man and the woman were both naked, but they were not embarrassed.

And so, we come to the creation of the as yet unnamed Eve. All powerful god couldn’t just make a woman out of soil, like he did Adam. Don’t be silly, that’d just make another man. He had to take a bone from Adam, obviously one that was superfluous to requirements, to do that. Did God not know how DNA works? What he was essentially doing was creating a clone of Adam. Now, I’m not up with the latest cloning techniques but I do know that if you clone a male, you’re going to get a male. So, this whole bone being necessary to avoid God just making another man is completely absurd, because of the laws of cloning and because, well, God is all powerful. It’s also bizarre to me that God didn’t realise earlier on when he was creating all the companion animals for Adam than none of them were going to work.

The last part of this passage is really odd. They were naked but not embarrassed. Well, they’d only just been created, so they didn’t know what embarrassment was, or nakedness for that fact, just like babies. And being embarrassed over nakedness is very much a social construct, not an inherently human one. Again, we’ll deal with this a bit more in the next Guide as we deal with consequences of eating the forbidden fruit. The concept of concealing the human form as a way to hide nakedness is a fairly recent idea. Early man used clothing in a far more practical manner, for protection from the weather. Even today, we see tribal societies who wear little to no clothes and have no concept of embarrassment about the human form, much to the horror of many a Christian missionary.

Next week, we’ll dissect the story of the disobedience of man, where Adam and Eve eat an apple at the behest of a talking snake.

Friday, April 24, 2020

An Athiests Guide to the Bible: The Story of Creation

In the beginning, when God created the universe ...

Well, that's a interesting way to start. Regardless of which version of the bible you read, they all start with this idea. That God created the universe. But what is God? Not who. What. Is the Christian god a physical being, an incorporeal consciousness or an idea dreamt up by man? Obviously, if it's the third option, then the whole concept of the bible is severely put in doubt. The idea that an idea could create anything is, quite frankly ludicrous.

So if we are to believe that the bible is not simply a book written by man to explain that which they do not understand, then God must be either a physical being or an incorporeal consciousness. If God were a physical being, you would think that someone would have spotted him. We have some very smart scientists, high ranking religious clergy, philosophers, and all manner of extraordinarily intelligent people in the world. None of them have shown any physical evidence for the undoubted existence of God as a corporeal being.

That leaves us with God being an incorporeal consciousness. So how do you prove the existence of something that has no physical presence? Well, the short answer is, you can't. And that's the mistake that so many people make about atheism. Atheism in it's purest form is the rejection of the belief in any god because we see no evidence for it, mainly because much of the argument for any god is exactly the same argument for any other god, and they can't all be correct.

Anyway, for the purposes of this post (and future Guide posts) let's assume that the Christian God of the bible I hold in my hand for the purposes of writing this series is an incorporeal consciousness. Now that we've defined what God is, we must define what the universe is. So let's see what my bible says about that ...
In the beginning, when God created the universe, the earth was formless and desolate. The raging ocean that covered everything was engulphed in total darkness, and the power of God was moving over the water. Then God commanded, "Let there be light" - and light appeared. God was please with what he saw. Then he separated the light from the darkness, and he named the light "Day and the darkness "Night." Evening passed and the morning came - that was the first day.

As someone who trusts the scientific explanation for the beginning of the known universe, this biblical explanation is troublesome. The first way in which is troubling is that is doesn't say how the universe was created. Of course, the bible was written at a time when physics of any description wasn't a thing. Even science struggles with the creation of the universe, so this isn't a criticism of the writers of the bible so much as a criticism of interpreters of the bible who think that a description of the beginning of the solar system is the equivalent of the a description of the beginning of the unknown universe.

The next troubling aspect is that the earth was created before light. Science tells us that the sun formed before the earth. The Sun has been around for around 5 billion years. The earth, young thing that it is, is only about 4.5 billion years. To give some context to just how young our solour system (and our earth is), the known universe itself is just under 14 billion years old. So it's not a great start for the bible.

The last bit that troubles me is the separation of light and dark to create day and night. We know that the sun provides the light for the earth and that the spin of the earth gives us day and night. We also know that there is not a distinct separation between light and dark because as the sun sets over the horizon the amount of visible light from the sun lessens, the reverse happening at sunrise. At its extremes we see how difference night and day are but it is extraordinarily hard for ordinary human beings to pick the point where day actually turns into night because, despite there being a time for sunset, the minute (or even the second) after that time is not exactly night, there still being light from the sun visible even thought the sun itself is not.

The bible continues ...
Then God commanded, "Let there be a dome to divide the water and to keep it in two separate places" - and it was done. So God made a dome, and it separated the water under it from the water above it. He named the dome "Sky." Evening passed and morning came - that was the end of the second day.
You can, naturally, imagine the writers of the bible looking at the sky and thinking that, because the sky was blue and the water was blue, there must be water above the sky to give it the colour. Today, many Christians will tell you that the dome is actually just the edge of the atmosphere in an effort to marry their faith and science. It fails to answer what the water above actually is and where it is located.
Then God commanded, "Let the water below the sky come together in one place, so that the land will appear" - and it was done. He named the land "Earth," and the water which had come together he named "Sea." And God was pleased with what he saw.

As far as the bible goes, this part I don't really have a problem with. We have earth and water. Ok, the water isn't just called sea, but oceans and lakes and rivers and all manner of different things. This is largely by the by, and if you're picking up on this point as something to argue against the validity of the bible, I think you're probably being a bit picky and a lot petty.
Then he commanded, "Let the earth produce all kinds of plants, those that bear grain and those that bear fruit" - and it was done. So the earth produced all kind of plants, and God was pleased with what he saw. Evening passed and morning came - that was the third day.

At this point, I have to leave what the bible actually says for a moment and remark upon the utter lack of creative thought that went into the writing of the bible. It feels like it was written by a small schoolchild who has been tasked with writing a narrative for the first time. It is very dry, almost procedural. The texts that engage people the best are not manuals but those where language engages the reader on a psychological and emotional level. The bible does neither.
Then God commanded, "Let lights appear in the sky to separate day from night and to show the time when days, years, and religious festivals begin; they will shine in the sky to give light to the earth" - and it was done. So God made the two larger lights, the sun to rule over the day and the moon to rule over the night; he also made the stars. He placed the lights in the sky to shine on the earth, to rule over the day and the night, and to separate light from darkness. And God was pleased with what he saw. Evening passed and morning came - that was the fourth day.

And this is where we go HANG ON A MINUTE! There is so much wrong with this passage. Not just in relation to the actual science of reality but simply as a consistent narrative. Let's start with the science. The moon is not a light in that it doesn't produce it's own light. It reflects the light of the sun, that's why we get eclipses. Also, the sun and moon and stars are not equidistant from Earth.

The moon is 384,400km from Earth.
The sun is 150,440,000km from Earth.
The nearest star is 4.37 light years from Earth.

The idea that all those things are attached to a dome over the earth is, given current scientific knowledge, absurd. Most Christians understand this. Most Christians have given away with a literal interpretation of the bible. They still believe that God created everything but they make the distinction between the difference in the understanding of man at the time of writing the bible and now, so far as to say that the people who wrote the bible didn't understand how God did it, so they made it up. My counterpoint is always that if they made up that bit, could they not just have made up the whole thing?

Apart from the lack of scientific reality, there is a huge disruption to the chronological progression of the narrative. On day one God created light but didn't create the sun until day four? This doesn't make any sense. Also, God separated the light and dark on day one but he's doing it again on day four? Did he forget? If he didn't forget, what was creating the light on day one and how was that different from the light the sun? This is but one of many contradictions or anomalies in the bible and we'll get to many of them in this series but let's move on ...
Then God commanded, "Let the water be filled with many kinds of living beings, and let the air be filled with birds." So God created the great sea monsters , all kinds of creatures that live in the water, and all kinds of birds. And God was pleased with what he saw. He blessed them all and told the creatures that live in the water to reproduce and to fill the sea, and he told the birds to increase in number. Evening passed and morning came - that was the fifth day.
Scientifically speaking, fish and birds were not even close to being the first living creatures. Maybe the writers of the bible just didn't think the previous creatures were important. The first creatures on earth were single celled organisms. OK, we are just repeating the argument that the writers of the bible probably didn't have any idea about science but this leads to a questioning of the concept that the bible is the direct word of God. If it's the direct word of God and the writers are simple transcribing it, then surely God would understand the science and be able to explain it in a way that the writers understood, without the huge gaps and errors, and why did God wait thousands of years between creating humans and starting his book? But I digress. Lets push on, we still have two days to go!
Then God commanded , "Let the earth produce all kinds of animal life; domestic and wild, large and small" - and it was done. So God made them all, and he was pleased with what he saw. Then God said, "And now we will make human beings; they will be like us and resemble us. They will have power over the fish , the birds and all animals, domestic and wild, large and small." So God created human beings, making them to be like himself. He created them male and female, blessed them, and said, "Have many children, so that your descendants will live all over the earth and bring it under their control. I am putting you in charge of the fish, the birds and all the wild animals. I have provided all kinds of grain and all kinds of fruit for you to eat; But for all the wild animals and for all the birds I have provided grass and leafy plants for food" - and it was done. God looked at everything he had made, and he was very pleased. Evening passed and morning came - that was the sixth day.

As a writer who got a distinction in grammar, I get very cranky when texts are not consistent in their tense or their pronouns. Here God refers to himself as we/us. There are a few explanations:

(a) There are many gods or God is talking to the angels.
(b) There's only one God but he's referring to the holy trinity
(c) There's only one God but he's using the royal "we"
(d) The writers stuffed up

If we are taking the atheistic position, this is clearly a stuff up by the writers. If we're taking the Christian position, it could be any of the other possibilities. This is not ever really reconciled. What is also not reconciled is that if God makes humans to be as himself, why are we not incorporeal consciousnesses? The fact that we have physical form could mean that this is the image the God has of himself or that God has a physical form. Going back to the opening of this post, if God had a physical form we, as a species, would have discovered a trace of it by now, one would think.
And so the whole universe was completed. By the seventh day God finished what he had been doing and stopped working. He blessed the seventh day and set it apart as a special day, because by that day he had completed his creation and stopped working. And that is how the universe was created.

Well, the solar system is not the universe, so that's a bit of a reach on behalf of the writers to claim that. It's not even all of the solar system, if we're being truthful. And there's not much of an explanation of the how, either. This is a huge problem I have with most religions, not just Christianity. God did it is not an explanation worthy of any enquiring mind, even if it was fundamentally true. If I built an amazing Lego world and someone asked you how it was made, and your answer was, "Nona did it" that would be true but not an explanation of how it was made.

But let's look at the story of Creation as a whole. It took 7 days. According to the bible, they were Earth Days as evening came at the end of each day, so seven lots of  24 and a bit hours going by current time telling techniques. But was it? Scientific studies of the bible have speculated that perhaps each day was an era, not a strict day as we know it. This is marginally closer to reality in that it allows time for evolution to take place but doesn't do anything to explain this process meaning that they thought this was unimportant, it didn't happen or the writers had no concept of it.

If you subscribe to a literal interpretation of the bible, you must deny the science that contradicts it and all the evidence which supports the science. I have talked to people both in real life and online who fall into this category. I have no problem with their belief in God but I do take issue with their rejection of evidence-based scepticism.

In the next Guide, in a few days time, we will look at the story of the Garden of Eden: its location and what it looked like. We will deal with the disobedience of man in the subsequent post.

Wednesday, April 4, 2012

Just do it yourself ...

I was thinking about what to write for my next blog post the other night and as I was skimming through people's posts on Facebook when I found an article that someone had read about the controversy over a picture an advertising company had used. I won't get into the details for two reasons: one is that I'm still going to write a post about that subject, the other is that the content of the picture or the controversy isn't important. The important thing is what happened next. I asked a certain subset of my Facebook friends to help me out with my post by supplying annectdotes or things they had come across which either supported or refuted my hypothesis. Now the subset I'm talking about isn't huge but they are usually quite a vocal bunch, like to add their two cents worth, so I expected at least a couple to reply. I got nothing. Not a single reply. I will admit, I sometimes ask questions at the wrong time of day and my requests get lost in the multitude of other Facebook posts that fill people's news feeds. I thought I'd done quite well with the timing of this one though. I think if I do ask again I will do it as a personal message and I wasn't all that fussed at not getting any replies. I did make me think if this was a gender thing (as I had asked only males to respond) or if it was a general indication of the lack of inclination to help others. I have always given an opinion or anecdote when asked. It's not that I think my opinion or story is any better than anyone else's, or that everyone should listen to it, I just think I have the right to a voice. Whether anyone is listening is beside the point. That is a lesson I learnt very early ... As a teenager in fact. Back then I was an aspiring poet, wanting my friends to read my work, to give feedback and validation. It didn't happen, of course. I'd ask and they'd feel like I was forcing them to read it so they wouldn't. I didn't really think I was forcing them. I thought I was doing exactly what my other poetically minded friends were doing. The difference was, I forgot it was a popularity contest when you're a teenager. I thought what's good for one is good for all. Sorry, kids, it isn't. If you want people to read your work, give it to an adult. Your friends don't care about your musings. They are too self absorbed, just like you are. So, I was once again transported to my teen angst as a 32 year old, and nothing much had changed. People are still self absorbed and it's still a popularity contest. The only difference between now and then is that I don't care. As a teenager, the rejection I felt was like a knife through my heart. It was the end of my world and my self belief took and almighty tumble. These days, it doesn't bother me. It's a quirk of life that somedays you'll be the bees knees and somedays you're the pigs arse. It's not the end of the world. It doesn't mean you're stupid or your question is invalid. It's just that people are too busy with their own lives to worry about some inconsequential query you may have. The lesson here is, it never hurts to ask for help but don't fly on the answer bing what you want or even for there to be an answer at all. If you want information about something, research it yourself, don't expect other people do your homework for you ... Just do it yourself.

Sunday, October 2, 2011

50 Questions Everyone Should Try To Answer

The following questions I found on the website: http://www.marcandangel.com/2009/07/13/50-questions-that-will-free-your-mind/ and thought I'd have a bash at answering them. My answers are only valid for me, your answers may be similar or very, very different.
 
How old would you be if you didn’t know how old you are?

You would be the same age as if you did know. Time is a concept invented by man based on the rotation of the earth and the orbit around the sun. This cycle continues regardless of whether we are aware of it as a passage of time.

OR

This question could mean to ask how old I would think I was, looking from the outside, as a stranger. In which case, on physical appearance I would probably think I was about the same age as I am, psychologically, I might think I was anywhere between 16 and 60 depending on the situation in which I observed myself.

Which is worse, failing or never trying?

They are equally as bad as each other, though the pain is different. I think that the pain of failing is short lived but more intense, whereas the pain of not trying is more subtle and lasts longer (or until you decide to try).

If life is so short, why do we do so many things we don’t like and like so many things we don’t do?

We do things we don’t like because we feel obliged to do them – visit family; go to a job just for the money and not for the enjoyment. Society often makes us feel bad for not doing the expected things, meaning that in order to get along, we do those things which we might not want to do.

I like motorbikes (I don’t own one or know how to ride one). I think there are two major reasons why we like things that we don’t do. One is the fear factor. We like the idea of doing something potentially dangerous but can’t bring ourselves to actually do it. The other factor is the time constraint. We get so caught up in our day to day lives that we find it hard to make the time to do that thing we like or try the thing we want to do.

When it’s all said and done, will you have said more than you’ve done?

I think I will have said more than I’ve done, not only because I like to talk and write but because there’s a lot I want to do but will probably never get around to doing. I think as long as you’re happy with what you have done and can live with what you’ve said you’d do and didn’t then it’s a life well lived.

What is the one thing you’d most like to change about the world?

The materialistic nature of society. I have no problem with ownership, I just have an issue with the cost of buying those things. Having withings and wanting things is not being materialistic. Wanting something because it is more expensive than something else, or because no-one else has it is materialistic. We have become a society that values the dollar more than we value our values.

If happiness was the national currency, what kind of work would make you rich?

I would do the same thing I do now, work with children in an active environment. I suppose, looking at it from the premise of this question, I am already as rich as I could ever hope to be.

Are you doing what you believe in, or are you settling for what you are doing?

I think my life is a mixture of both. I love what I do and I believe in the value of doing it as fulfilment of myself: being a parent, the work I do, the other interests I have and partake in. I have also settled in that I haven’t tried in any real sense to extend myself or better myself recently.

If the average human life span was 40 years, how would you live your life differently?

Probably not. I might date a bit more. And it depends on whether it was the same process of aging but sped up to shorten the lifespan to 40 years or whether you aged as you do now, then dropped dead at 40.

To what degree have you actually controlled the course your life has taken?

I think it’s about 50/50. Somethings have been completely my own choosing. Some have been influenced by others and some things have been forced upon me (both good and bad).

Are you more worried about doing things right, or doing the right things?

Again, I think I worry about both. I want to do things right, I am a perfectionist. I also want to do the right things (as seen by others and by myself). I would like to be able to worry less about the outcome, rather than the reason behind what I am doing.

You’re having lunch with three people you respect and admire.  They all start criticizing a close friend of yours, not knowing she is your friend.  The criticism is distasteful and unjustified.  What do you do?

With all due respect and admiration to the people I am with, I would correct them if they said something erroneous about a friend of mine and have done this before. I think if they are critising based on information that is flawed then I should correct the information so they can come to an informed critique of the person and/or their actions.

If you could offer a newborn child only one piece of advice, what would it be?

Learn from the mistakes of others, it saves you having to make the same mistakes yourself.

Would you break the law to save a loved one?

Yes. There is no hesitation in answering this. I would do anything to protect and/or save my family and close friends.

Have you ever seen insanity where you later saw creativity?

I’m not sure about insanity, but stupidity definitely. I recently had a revelation, or maybe a reawakening of a thought: A person can be incredibly creative in one manner and yet you find the rest of their work to be incredibly stupid.

What’s something you know you do differently than most people?

Eat spaghetti / noodles.

How come the things that make you happy don’t make everyone happy?

Individuality: culture, religion, generation gap, gender, sexuality, friends, family, genetics. There are probably a few basic, fundamental phenomena that make most people happy but all in all be are a product of what we are, what we experience and what we gain from the experience which makkes each individual unique.

What one thing have you not done that you really want to do?  What’s holding you back?

Sky Dive: money, time, encouragement, fear.

Are you holding onto something you need to let go of?

The idea of the perfect man.

If you had to move to a state or country besides the one you currently live in, where would you move and why?

Interstate: Tasmania – it’s beautiful and it’s not busy
International: Scotland or Ireland – the accent

Do you push the elevator button more than once?  Do you really believe it makes the elevator faster?

Yes. No.

Would you rather be a worried genius or a joyful simpleton?

A worried genius because if I were a genius I could figure out a way to solve what was worrying me and then be a joyful genius.

Why are you, you?

Because my brain is wired aspecific way so that it experiences things in certain way and informs future decisions based on what has gone before. In other words, a little bit of nature and a little bit of nurture working together.

Have you been the kind of friend you want as a friend?

Not always but mostly and I hope increasingly more so.

Which is worse, when a good friend moves away, or losing touch with a good friend who lives right near you?

Losing touch with a good friend who lives near by because there is nothing you can blame the loss on but yourself because distance isn’t a factor.

What are you most grateful for?

Choosing not to follow through with thoughts of suicide when I was younger because if I had, I’d never have had my son.

Would you rather lose all of your old memories, or never be able to make new ones?

There’s some old memories that I’d like to lose but I think I’d rather not be able to make new ones because I could document my present in some way, through writing it down or videoing it and not have to rely on memory, whereas the old memories have no backup.

Is is possible to know the truth without challenging it first?

No. You can have faith in it being the truth, but you can never really know that it is the truth unless you have challenged it and seen the result for yourself.

Has your greatest fear ever come true?

My greatest fear is being without a partner for the rest of my life. This can only come true the moment I die, so the answer is no.

Do you remember that time 5 years ago when you were extremely upset?  Does it really matter now?

No, and clearly not, because I don’t remember it.

What is your happiest childhood memory?  What makes it so special?

Finding out someone had a crush on me. It made me believe that I could be just like the other girls.

At what time in your recent past have you felt most passionate and alive?

At the football, cheering on my beloved Sydney Swans with my son and my friends.

If not now, then when?

When it’s convenient, when I have the money, when I have the time, when I have the energy.

If you haven’t achieved it yet, what do you have to lose?

It depends on what the achievent is. If you give up nothing for an achievement, then what have you really achieved. We all give up something to achieve: time, money, other opportunities. The real question is whether they are worth losing.

Have you ever been with someone, said nothing, and walked away feeling like you just had the best conversation ever?

Yes :D

Why do religions that support love cause so many wars?

Because most religions support love of an ideal which may be different from another religions ideal and so in order to “save” the followers of the other religion they feel that they must destroy all opposition to their ideal.

Is it possible to know, without a doubt, what is good and what is evil?

In some cases, yes. In some cases no. I believe that nothing is good or evil except the intention which makes it so.

If you just won a million dollars, would you quit your job?

No, because a million dollars doesn’t go very far these days.

Would you rather have less work to do, or more work you actually enjoy doing?

More work I enjoy doing.

Do you feel like you’ve lived this day a hundred times before?

Sometimes.

When was the last time you marched into the dark with only the soft glow of an idea you strongly believed in?

When I started this blog. It’s not much but I believe in it.

If you knew that everyone you know was going to die tomorrow, who would you visit today?

My son.

Would you be willing to reduce your life expectancy by 10 years to become extremely attractive or famous?

No, because in those 10 years I may find someone who can see past my physical imperfections or become famous on my own.

What is the difference between being alive and truly living?

Being alive is survival mode, truly living is make the most out of every experience, trying new things, being the best person that you can be.

When is it time to stop calculating risk and rewards, and just go ahead and do what you know is right?

In my case, never. Or when the risk is negligable and the reward guaranteed.

If we learn from our mistakes, why are we always so afraid to make a mistake?

The percieved pressure we feel to be perfect.

What would you do differently if you knew nobody would judge you?

Say yes more often when I was younger and no more often now I’m older.

When was the last time you noticed the sound of your own breathing?

Everytime I yawn I notice my breathing.

What do you love?  Have any of your recent actions openly expressed this love?

I love my son. I tell him all the time. I love writing. I do it as often as I can.

In 5 years from now, will you remember what you did yesterday?  What about the day before that?  Or the day before that?

No, not specifically, as it is an ordinary day.

Decisions are being made right now.  The question is:  Are you making them for yourself, or are you letting others make them for you?

Both.